Room for Peace

Regional and civil initiativesIsrael and the Palestinian territories (civil initiatives)

Two states in partnership: confederation models

Initiative or proposalProposal, not adopted

Two unofficial proposals by public figures and activists. Both propose two independent, sovereign states cooperating within a confederal framework: not a single state, and not an agreement anyone has signed.

In one sentence

To let two sovereign states share one land: a real border, but an open one, and joint institutions for joint matters.

In 30 seconds

What if there were two states, and you could still move freely between them? A Land for All, an Israeli–Palestinian movement that grew out of a 2012 meeting, proposes just that: two independent states based on the 1967 lines, open borders and shared institutions.⁠1 The Holy Land Confederation, edited by Hiba Husseini and Yossi Beilin in 2022, sees confederation as a way to make two states possible, not to replace them.⁠2

Where it stands today

As of October 2026 both proposals remain civil-society ideas: no government has adopted them, and no permanent-status negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians are under way.⁠3

Status checked on

The challenge

Separation plans kept hitting the same questions: what happens to hundreds of thousands of settlers, to the refugees and to Jerusalem. According to the confederation authors, both peoples are attached to the whole land, which makes full separation especially hard.⁠1

Hence the idea: two states and a border between them, but with movement, residence and cooperation across it. Both models stress that these are two separate sovereignties.⁠42

The road there

  1. A meeting in Beit Jala of about ten Israelis and a similar number of Palestinians, initiated by journalist Meron Rapoport and activist Awni al-Mashni, gives rise to the movement Two States, One Homeland, later A Land for All.⁠14
  2. The Holy Land Confederation proposal is published, edited by Hiba Husseini and Yossi Beilin, after work by a joint team in 2020⁠–⁠2022.⁠2

The people

What was proposed

  1. A Land for All: two states based on the 1967 lines, open borders, an open, shared Jerusalem and joint institutions. Israelis could live in Palestine and Palestinians in Israel as residents, each keeping their own citizenship; each state keeps its own security forces, which cooperate.⁠14
  2. Holy Land: a border based on the Green Line with one-to-one swaps, following the Geneva Initiative maps; a corridor under Palestinian administration between the West Bank and Gaza.⁠5
  3. Holy Land: settlers beyond the border could move to Israel or stay as permanent residents of Palestine under Palestinian law; a similar number of Palestinians would get permanent residence in Israel.⁠25
  4. Holy Land: Jerusalem as the capital of both states and a partly open city; at first only the Old City is open.⁠5
  5. Holy Land: no confederal army; each state keeps its own security forces, with initial limits on Palestine's weapons and a third-party force on its territory. A 30-month implementation period, a review every five years, and an option to dissolve the confederation without changing the border.⁠5

The geography

100%
Schematic map of Israel and its neighbours with line typesWest BankGaza StripJerusalemTel AvivGazaRamallahAmmanRafahNaharayim / Baqura
How to use the map

Choose a country on the map or in the list. One finger scrolls the page; two fingers move and pinch the map. You can also use + and −. For one-finger map dragging, enable the button above. Keyboard: arrows to pan, + and − to zoom, Home to reset.

Layers

Classification follows the original research as of 7 Oct 2026. This schematic map is not a legal boundary map or a live update.

  • International boundary agreed in a peace treaty
  • Treaty line with Jordan, “without prejudice to the status” of the territory beyond it
  • 1949 armistice line (“Green Line”) — not an agreed final border
  • “Blue Line” — UN line of withdrawal (2000), not a border
  • Ceasefire / disengagement line with Syria (1974)
  • Other international boundary
  • West Bank and Gaza Strip: permanent status not agreed
  • Golan Heights: held by Israel since 1967; annexation not recognised by the UN
  • UN area of separation (UNDOF); Israeli army positions inside it since December 2024

Schematic map. Lines are approximate and are not a legal determination. Data: Natural Earth (public domain), 1:10m scale; line classification and place names by this site. Lines as of October 2026. Peace map

The hard decisions

  • Criticism of the confederation idea (Shira Efron and Evan Gottesman, +972 Magazine, 2021): open borders clash with Israel's security doctrine, and the power gap would remain, leaving Palestine the weaker partner and Palestinians possibly not feeling truly sovereign. They add that a 2021 RAND study found the idea little known, with low acceptance.⁠6
  • Criticism of the Holy Land proposal (Yossi Alpher, Americans for Peace Now, 2022): leaving about 200,000 settlers on Palestinian territory is in his view a recipe for friction and violence; admitting Palestinians into Israel could be read as realising the right of return; and confederations, he argues, have not lasted.⁠7
  • The barriers: Meron Rapoport, a founder of A Land for All, admits that the idea raises questions that are hard to answer today, from settlements and the right of return to Jerusalem, economic gaps and security.⁠1 Alpher notes that the proposal has no real political backing for now.⁠7

Where accounts differ

According to A Land for All
Full separation does not fit both peoples' attachment to the whole land; two states with an open border and shared institutions allow injustices to be redressed without creating new ones.⁠1
According to The authors of the Holy Land Confederation
Confederation is not a substitute for the two-state solution but a way to make it possible, partly because it does not require a mass evacuation of settlers.⁠2
According to Shira Efron and Evan Gottesman
The confederation model does not solve the problems of security, sovereignty and unequal power, and sometimes sharpens them.⁠6
According to Yossi Alpher
The proposal does not explain why a confederation would solve the settlement and security problems better than an ordinary two-state arrangement.⁠7

What was carried out 0

—

What was not 1

  • Neither proposal has been adopted by the Government of Israel or the PLO, and neither has reached an official negotiating table.⁠3

What remains open

  • A confederation is not a single state: in both proposals each people has its own state, citizenship and institutions.⁠45 The difference from separation plans lies in how open the border is and in the status of those living on the other side.
  • The proposals do not answer every question in the same detail: in the Holy Land proposal the refugee issue rests on earlier frameworks without numbers,⁠5 and in A Land for All the security arrangements are stated as a general principle.⁠4

Sources

Open the sources, compare and check for yourself.

What can this source tell us?

A document shows what was written; testimony tells what someone saw or remembers; research and reporting add interpretation and comparison. Always ask who produced the information and what still needs checking. The label alone does not establish quality, and two sites copying one document still give you one source.

Practise checking sources
Show all sources (7)Hide the sources

Cited on this page

  1. From the Margins to the Heart of the Public Debate: The Confederation Idea in Israeli Discourse (Meron Rapoport)Research The Forum for Regional Thinking1 December 2023
  2. The Holy Land Confederation (2022)Research Economic Cooperation Foundation (ECF)7 February 2022
  3. The Middle East, including the Palestinian Question — October 2026 Monthly ForecastResearch Security Council Report2026
  4. A Land for All — Two States, One Homeland (the movement's principles)Primary A Land for All
  5. The Holy Land Confederation as a Facilitator for the Two-State Solution — English, 1st edition (2022)Primary Economic Cooperation Foundation (ECF)2022
  6. Is Israeli-Palestinian confederation all it's hyped up to be? (Shira Efron and Evan Gottesman)Press +972 Magazine3 May 2021
  7. Hard Questions, Tough Answers (Yossi Alpher) — on the Holy Land Confederation proposalResearch Americans for Peace Now21 February 2022