Room for Peace

Regional and civil initiativesSigned in July 2024; presented at the Vatican in October 2024

The Olmert–al-Kidwa proposal

Initiative or proposalProposal, not adopted

An unofficial initiative: a short outline signed by two former senior office-holders acting as private individuals. It is not an agreement and binds no government.

In one sentence

In the middle of the Gaza war, to offer both a way to end it and the baselines of a two-state agreement.

In 30 seconds

On 17 July 2024, with the war in Gaza raging, two veterans of past talks signed a joint plan: Ehud Olmert, a former prime minister of Israel, and Nasser al-Kidwa, a former Palestinian foreign minister.⁠1 First a ceasefire and the release of the hostages; then two states based on the 1967 lines, with a 4.4% land swap.⁠2

Where it stands today

As of October 2026 the proposal remains a document by two private individuals: no government has adopted it, and no permanent-status negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians are under way.⁠3

Status checked on

The challenge

In July 2024 the war in Gaza that followed the Hamas-led terrorist attack of 7 October 2023 was still being fought, and there were no political talks. A day after the outline was signed, the Knesset voted 68 to 9 for a resolution opposing a Palestinian state.⁠4

Both authors knew the issues first-hand. In 2008 Olmert put a proposal and a map before Mahmoud Abbas in the talks that followed Annapolis;⁠5 al-Kidwa was Palestinian foreign minister in 2005⁠–⁠2006.⁠6

The road there

  1. Ehud Olmert, then prime minister, presents a proposal and a map to Mahmoud Abbas; the talks end without an agreement.⁠5
  2. Olmert and Nasser al-Kidwa sign the joint outline.⁠1
  3. The text is published in the media, including the magazine Al Majalla.⁠7
  4. The two present the proposal to Pope Francis at the Vatican.⁠6

The people

What was proposed

  1. In Gaza: a ceasefire, the release of the Israeli hostages and of an agreed number of Palestinian prisoners, and a full Israeli withdrawal from the Strip.⁠1
  2. After the war: a Council of Commissioners made up of professionals, not politicians, to run and rebuild Gaza, linked to the Palestinian Authority. General elections in the West Bank and Gaza within 24 to 36 months.⁠21
  3. A temporary Arab security presence in Gaza, coordinated with the Israeli withdrawal, to prevent attacks on Israel; a donors' conference for reconstruction.⁠2
  4. Two states based on the 1967 lines: Israel annexes 4.4% of the West Bank, in areas to be agreed, and hands over territory of equal size, including a corridor between Gaza and the West Bank.⁠26
  5. Jerusalem as the capital of both states: Jewish neighbourhoods to Israel, Arab neighbourhoods to Palestine. The Old City would be run by a trusteeship of five states, among them Israel and Palestine, with no state holding exclusive sovereignty.⁠27
  6. The Palestinian state would be non-militarised, apart from a police and internal security force.⁠2

The geography

100%
Schematic map of Israel and its neighbours with line typesWest BankGaza StripJerusalemTel AvivGazaRamallahAmmanRafahNaharayim / Baqura
How to use the map

Choose a country on the map or in the list. One finger scrolls the page; two fingers move and pinch the map. You can also use + and −. For one-finger map dragging, enable the button above. Keyboard: arrows to pan, + and − to zoom, Home to reset.

Layers

Classification follows the original research as of 7 Oct 2026. This schematic map is not a legal boundary map or a live update.

  • International boundary agreed in a peace treaty
  • Treaty line with Jordan, “without prejudice to the status” of the territory beyond it
  • 1949 armistice line (“Green Line”) — not an agreed final border
  • “Blue Line” — UN line of withdrawal (2000), not a border
  • Ceasefire / disengagement line with Syria (1974)
  • Other international boundary
  • West Bank and Gaza Strip: permanent status not agreed
  • Golan Heights: held by Israel since 1967; annexation not recognised by the UN
  • UN area of separation (UNDOF); Israeli army positions inside it since December 2024

Schematic map. Lines are approximate and are not a legal determination. Data: Natural Earth (public domain), 1:10m scale; line classification and place names by this site. Lines as of October 2026. Peace map

The hard decisions

  • The main barrier: Olmert and al-Kidwa hold no office,⁠6 and have no mandate to negotiate for the Government of Israel or the PLO.
  • The outline leaves core issues to official negotiations: settlements and settlers, the refugees, and further security arrangements.⁠2
  • Critics quoted in the SA Jewish Report: details are missing on the land swap and the Arab force, and it is unclear whether the Palestinian Authority could play its part (Hussein Solomon); the authors repeat earlier proposals without tackling what stopped them (Glen Segell); and Israelis, then focused on the hostages and the war, would not accept a divided Jerusalem (Rolene Marks).⁠8
  • Documented reactions are few. The Catholic Review noted strong critics among both Israelis and Palestinians, without details;⁠6 no official response from the Government of Israel, the Palestinian Authority or Hamas was found.

Where accounts differ

According to The authors of the proposal
A way to end the war in Gaza and a two-state horizon can be offered at the same time. According to al-Kidwa, linking Gaza's administration to the Palestinian Authority is meant to keep the territory, and the Palestinian people, united.⁠1
According to Critics interviewed by the SA Jewish Report (a single outlet)
The proposal does not match the mood of the Israeli public and is not workable in the near term.⁠8

What was carried out 0

—

What was not 1

  • The proposal never became official negotiations, and no government adopted it.⁠3

What remains open

  • The outline does not name the three other states in the Old City trusteeship; it recognises the special historic role of the King of Jordan.⁠2
  • The description rests on the text published by Al Majalla and by the website The Third Narrative.⁠72
  • The Gaza ceasefire of October 2025 came by a different route, the US plan; see the Gaza ceasefire.

Sources

Open the sources, compare and check for yourself.

What can this source tell us?

A document shows what was written; testimony tells what someone saw or remembers; research and reporting add interpretation and comparison. Always ask who produced the information and what still needs checking. The label alone does not establish quality, and two sites copying one document still give you one source.

Practise checking sources
Show all sources (8)Hide the sources

Cited on this page

  1. Report on the joint Olmert–al-Kidwa proposal (Jerusalem Post staff)Press The Jerusalem Post9 September 2024
  2. Olmert–AlKidwa Outline for a Two-State Peace Agreement (reproduction of the outline)Reference The Third Narrative6 September 2024
  3. The Middle East, including the Palestinian Question — October 2026 Monthly ForecastResearch Security Council ReportOctober 2026
  4. Israel's Knesset votes to reject Palestinian statehoodPress Al Jazeera18 July 2024
  5. Abbas on Olmert's 2008 peace offer (report by Julie Wiener)Press Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA)19 November 2015
  6. Pope meets former Israeli and Palestinian officials promoting peacePress Catholic Review17 October 2024
  7. Al Majalla publishes Olmert-Kidwa peace proposalPress Al Majalla7 September 2024
  8. Proposed peace plan has no wings, say experts (Steven Gruzd)Press SA Jewish Report12 September 2024