Room for Peace

How to check us: a source in five steps

You do not have to take our word for anything on this site. Here is how to check a claim in five steps, with one example followed from start to finish.

5 min read

Why check at all

This site is written in Israel, through Israeli eyes, and it says so openly. That is a reason to check it, not a reason to dismiss it and not a reason to trust it: everyone who writes stands somewhere, and the fair ones tell you where.

Trust cannot be asked for. It is built one claim at a time, when you open the source and find in it what we said was in it. That is why every substantive claim on the site has a small number next to it that leads to a source.

Checking is also a skill you take with you. The same five steps work on a post, on a clip that reached your phone, on a politician's speech and on a school textbook.

The five steps

1. Find the small number and open the source
Next to a claim you will see a small number. It leads to the list at the foot of the page, where the source has a name, a publisher and a link. Open it. If an important claim has no number at all, that too is a finding.
2. See what kind of source it is, and who published it
The site tags every source: primary (the text of an agreement, an official transcript, a UN document), official archive, research, press, or reference. A primary source shows what was said or signed; research and press tell you what someone made of it. Then ask who the publisher is and what stake it has in the story.
3. Read the sentence in the source, not only the headline
Search the page for the name, the date or the number you are checking, and read the lines around it. Does the source say what we said, or something similar but weaker, older or more hedged? A link that opens proves only that the page exists.
4. Look for a second source, from another side
One source is a start. Look for the same event in a place that sees it from a different angle: the UN document system⁠1 and its collection on the question of Palestine,⁠2 the Israel State Archives⁠3 and the Knesset website,⁠4 the Office of the Historian at the US State Department,⁠5 the Palestinian news agency WAFA,⁠6 the Institute for Palestine Studies and its encyclopedia PalQuest,⁠78 and for the present day also B'Tselem⁠9 and the UN humanitarian office OCHA.⁠10 Agreement between sources is a clue to investigate: two websites may repeat the same report. Check who observed the event, who reported it, and what evidence each account relies on. When accounts differ, compare their evidence and say what remains uncertain. Different perspectives do not give every claim equal evidentiary weight.
5. Separate fact, interpretation and position, and ask what a number counts
“The treaty was signed on 26 March 1979” is a fact. “The treaty was a turning point” is an interpretation. “The treaty was a betrayal” or “a triumph” is a position. With numbers, ask three things: who counted, what the figure includes and what it leaves out, and as of what date.

One example from the site: “No more wars”

Many people remember the line as “No more wars” and attribute it to Menachem Begin at the signing of the peace treaty with Egypt. On this site the quotation reads “No more war, no more bloodshed, no more bereavement”.⁠11 The difference is one letter. Let us check which is right.

The five steps, applied

Step 1: the number
The quotation card has a source line: the remarks of President Carter, President Sadat and Prime Minister Begin at the signing ceremony, as published by The American Presidency Project.⁠11 The link opens.
Step 2: the kind of source
It is a transcript of the ceremony from the official record of the US presidents (the Public Papers of the Presidents), published by a project of the University of California, Santa Barbara.⁠11 So it is a primary source for the words spoken in English that day, and the publisher has no reason to prefer one letter to another. It is still an American record, and a careful reader notes that as well.
Step 3: the sentence itself
Search the page for the word “bereavement”. In Begin's remarks, dated 26 March 1979, the text reads “No more war, no more bloodshed, no more bereavement”.⁠11 That is “war”, in the singular. These words close a longer sentence, which is why the site says so on the card and does not present them as a sentence standing alone. In the same transcript the plural, “wars”, appears in Sadat's remarks and not in Begin's.⁠11
Step 4: a second source
Here the site admits a limit. The transcript is one record, in English, of a ceremony held in English. A sound or film recording of the ceremony, or the Israeli record of that day, would be a real second source, and you can look for them yourself in the Israel State Archives.⁠3 Until then the right thing to say is “according to the official US transcript”, which is exactly how the quotation is labelled on the site.
Step 5: fact, interpretation, position
Fact: the transcript has “war”, not “wars”. Interpretation: why memory changed the word; perhaps because the plural sounds more like a slogan, perhaps because Sadat used it, and we do not know. Position: whether the promise was kept is something people argue about to this day, and no transcript will settle it. The difference here is one letter, but the same steps catch bigger things too.

Sources

Open the sources, compare and check for yourself.

What can this source tell us?

A document shows what was written; testimony tells what someone saw or remembers; research and reporting add interpretation and comparison. Always ask who produced the information and what still needs checking. The label alone does not establish quality, and two sites copying one document still give you one source.

Practise checking sources
Show all sources (11)Hide the sources

Cited on this page

  1. Official Document System (search by document symbol, in the six UN languages)Primary United Nations
  2. History of the Question of PalestinePrimary United Nations (UNISPAL)
  3. Online catalogue and document collectionsOfficial archive Israel State Archives
  4. Knesset website (plenary records, laws)Official archive The Knesset
  5. Milestones and Foreign Relations of the United States (FRUS)Official archive U.S. Department of State, Office of the Historian
  6. News service of the Palestinian AuthorityPress WAFA, Palestine News and Information Agency
  7. Journals, documents and chronologiesResearch Institute for Palestine Studies
  8. PalQuest: Interactive Encyclopedia of the Palestine QuestionResearch Institute for Palestine Studies / Palestinian Museum
  9. The Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied TerritoriesReference B'Tselem
  10. Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, occupied Palestinian territoryResearch UN OCHA
  11. Remarks of President Carter, President Anwar al-Sadat of Egypt, and Prime Minister Menahem Begin of Israel at the Egyptian-Israeli Peace Treaty Signing CeremonyPrimary The American Presidency Project, UC Santa Barbara (Public Papers of the Presidents)26 March 1979